Indonesia
On October 12, 2002,
two suicide bombers affiliated with Jemaah Islamiyyah
(JI), a radical Islamist network that aims to create a regional Islamic superstate
in Southeast Asia, bombed two nightclubs on the tourist island of Bali, killing
202 people, including 88 Australian tourists. The attacks, which had originally
been planned in Thailand, were funded by KSM, who transferred funds to Riduan Isamuddin, better known as
Hambali, Al Qaeda’s senior operative in Southeast
Asia. The planning of the Bali attacks lasted for about eight months and was
facilitated by means of a local infrastructure of operatives from Afghanistan
who had previously acquired operational experience. In deciding to employ the
tactic of suicide operations, the planners were heavily influenced by Al Qaeda,
who had long preferred SAs to maximize both casualties as well as the element
of fear.( Schweitzer and Ferber, "Al Qaeda and the Internationalization of
Suicide Terrorism," 66-67.) Following the October 2002 bombings, one JI
defendant blamed the attack as a result of imperialist, pro-Israeli, and
anti-Muslim policy. Bin Laden, meanwhile, blamed “Australian imperialism” for
the attack in a videotape he sent to the Al Jazeera satellite TV station.
Australian intervention in East Timor, bin Laden claimed, was a usurpation of
Muslim land. Schweitzer believes that blaming U.S. policies was the result of
indoctrination and training JI members received in bin Laden-sponsored training
camps in Afghanistan. (Yoram Schweitzer, "Global Jihad as Reaction to
American Policy: A Dangerous Delusion," Tel AvivNotes
No. 118, 9 December 2004).
On August 5, 2003, JI
staged another suicide operation at the JW Marriott Hotel in Jakarta, using a
sports utility vehicle to maximize the effects of the blast. (Keith Bradsher,
"Indonesia Bombing Kills at Least 10 in Midday Attack," New York Times,
6 August 2003, 1.) The attack was financed by the same funds that KSM had
transferred to Hambali for the preceding year’s
attacks in Bali. 13 months later, on September 9, 2004, two suicide bombers
detonated themselves in a white delivery truck near the Australian embassy in
Jakarta, killing nine people and injuring 180. On October 1, 2005, three
suicide bombers struck Bali a second time, killing 19 people and wounding some
90. Many of the casualties were dining in the three restaurants that were
targeted, one on a busy street and two located at a beachfront five miles away.
Indonesian security services blamed two Malaysian JI operatives, Azhari Husin,
and Muhammad Noordin Top, with masterminding the operation as well as the
attacks on the Marriot hotel two years earlier. (Raymond Bonner and Jane
Perlez, "Macabre Clues Advance Inquiry in Bali Attacks," New York
Times, 3 October 2005, 1.) Husin detonated himself some five weeks after the
bombings, when counter-terrorist units closed in on his safe house in Java. The
Bali attacks, including the training of suicide bombers and the assembly of the
backpack bombs used, were reportedly planned in the Philippines. (Raymond
Bonner, "Slow Progress in Bali Inquiry Hints at Wilier Terror
Groups," New York Times, 27 October 2005, 6.)
Casablanca, Morocco
On May 16, 2003, 14
suicide bombers attacked a Spanish-owned restaurant, a hotel, a Jewish
cemetery, a Jewish community center, and an Italian restaurant in the Moroccan
city of Casablanca. 12 of the attackers completed their mission, killing 33
innocent civilians in the process and injuring over 100 others. According to
reports, the perpetrators were loosely linked to the Moroccan Islamic Combatant
Group (GICM). Several of the would-be suicide bombers told their interrogators
later that they were part of Ahl Sunna wal Jama’a, i.e., Salafi-oriented Sunni Muslims. (Alison
Pargeter, “The Islamist Movement in Morocco,” Terrorism Monitor 3, no. 10,
2005). The cell responsible for the attacks had formed around a nucleus
of Moroccan veterans of terrorist training camps in Afghanistan who regarded
bin Laden as an inspirational leader. (Thomas Omestad,
“The Casbah Connection: Why Morocco Is Producing Some of the World’s Most
Feared Terrorists,” U.S. News & World Report, 9 May 2005.) The suicide
bombers, most of whom where from Sidi Moumen, a
squalid shantytown (bidonville) outside central Casablanca, were reportedly
under the ideological influence of Mohammed Fizazi, a
Moroccan preacher imprisoned in Tangier for inspiring the bombings in
Casablanca, and who has also been linked to some individuals involved in the
9/11 and the Madrid attacks of March 11, 2004. (Terry McDermott, “Moroccan
Preacher Said to Have Met with 9/11 Plotters,” Los Angeles Times, 6 July,
2005.) They regularly prayed in local mosques where clerics preached jihad
against infidels, and advocated the severing of ties to the Moroccan
establishment. (Schweitzer and Ferber, “Al Qaeda and the Internationalization
of Suicide Terrorism,” 68.) The nature of the connection of the Moroccan cell
to Al Qaeda remains unknown. Morocco sentenced Abdelkarim Mejjati,
a former medical student from Morocco who died in a gun battle in Saudi Arabia
in April 2005, for 20 years in absentia for his involvement in the Casablanca
attacks. A multi-lingual jihadist and skilled bomb-maker of privileged
upbringing, Mejatti was also believed to have helped
organize the network that blew up three residential compounds for foreign
workers in Riyadh on May 12, 2003. The Washington Post reported in 2005 that
Moroccan investigators, who at first believed that the operation was conceived
and planned locally, subsequently changed their mind when they apprehended a
suspect who divulged Mejjati’s name to interrogators,
who concluded that those responsible for the attacks were taking cues from Al
Qaeda’s top leadership. (Craig Whitlock, “Odyssey of an Al Qaeda Operative,”
Washington Post, 2 May 2005, A1.)
Saudi Arabia
Saudi Arabia has long
been a prime target for Al Qaeda and its affiliates, especially since the early
1990s, when the ruling family welcomed American troops on its soil. Beginning
in 2003, Saudi Arabia was first targeted by SAs. In May, three cells of members
of a terrorist network supported by Al Qaeda in Saudi Arabia, each consisting
between 9 and 12 members, staged simultaneous attacks on three residential
complexes in the capital Riyadh. The attacks combined traditional SA operations
with rifle attacks against the compound, which housed mostly foreigners
consulting Saudi businesses and the military. The attackers first gunned down
guards at the complex, thus clearing the path for the entry of bomb-laden cars
driven by suicide operatives. 29 people, including eight Americans, were killed
in these attacks. (Schweitzer and Ferber, "Al Qaeda and the
Internationalization of Suicide Terrorism," 70-71.) Additional SAs were
staged first on November 8 of the same years at the al-Muhi residential complex
in Riyadh, which housed foreign workers. The attacks killed 17 people and
injured 122. The operation was similar to the May 2003 attack in that rifle
firing units cleared the way for explosives-laden cars. Another attack occurred
on April 21, 2004 at the headquarters of the Saudi special forces, which again
took the form of a suicide car bombing, killing four people and injuring 150.
An unknown group, the ‘Battalions of the Two Holy Sites on the Arabian
Peninsula,’ posted an announcement on an Islamic website claiming that it was
“following the path of Bin Laden and Al Qaeda.” The attack was a turning point
because unlike in previous attacks, most casualties were Saudi civilian
employees, leading many Saudis to condemn these attacks. Future attacks would
henceforth avoid mass-casualty attacks on Saudi citizens. (Craig Whitlock,
"Al Qaeda Shifts Its Strategy in Saudi Arabia," Washington Post, 19
December 2004, 28.) In Khobar, on May 29, 2004, a cell consisting of four
attackers attacked three Western oil company offices. Although it planned to
detonate a suicide car bomb, the plan did not materialize and turned into a
siege situation, in the course of which the attackers killed 16 hostages,
including all non-Muslims. Seven months later to the day, terrorists detonated an
explosives-laden car near the Ministry of the Interior through remote control,
while two suicide bombers detonated a booby-trapped car that they tried to ram
into a recruitment center of the Saudi Emergency Forces, who had recently begun
to focus their work on counterterrorism. ("Car Bombers Target Saudi
Security Units," Washington Post 2004 Neil MacFarquhar, "Suicide
Bomber Attacks Saudi Arabia's Interior Ministry," New York Times, 30
December 2004, 8.)
As Osama bin Laden
and Zawahiri had frequently called for, Salafi-Jihadists also targeted the oil
industry in an additional effort to undermine the Saudi royal family’s grip on
Saudi Arabia and hit Western oil interests.(Specifically, bin Laden called for
attacks against oil facilities in a December 2004 audio message, which was
followed by Zawahiri in the autumn of 2005). A first SA against an
oil-processing plant was foiled in February 2006 when Saudi security opened
fire at two cars approaching the Abqaiq plant in the eastern Dammam province,
causing the vehicles to detonate. (See Simon Henderson, "Al-Qaeda Attack
on Abqaiq: The Vulnerability of Saudi Oil," PolicyWatch
No. 1082, 28 February 2006).Shortly after the attempted attack, Al Qaeda
assumed responsibility for the failed operation and promised to launch
additional strikes on oil facilities to force “infidels” out of Saudi Arabia
and prevent further “theft” of Muslim wealth by “Crusaders and Jews.”1 Yoram
Schweitzer describes the relationship between Al Qaeda and the terrorist
networks operating in the Arabian peninsula as one akin to a parent
organization and its offshoots. The connection between the central Al Qaeda
leadership and the Saudi branch, he writes, was maintained by senior commanders
who worked for years closely with senior Al Qaeda members in Afghanistan. These
commanders directed the networks operating on the peninsula after returning to
Saudi Arabia. These commanders included Yousef al-Ayeri
and Abdul Aziz al-Muqrin who, until their death, were chiefly responsible for
importing the concept of self-sacrifice into the peninsula. Schweitzer
concludes that “the adoption of suicide attacks as the leading mode of
operation for terrorist activity in Saudi Arabia and the accompanying rhetoric appearing
in claims of responsibility attests to the internalization of al-Qaeda’s
principles and ideology by its affiliates.”2 These principles were also
reflected in a video statement released by Al Qaeda in Saudi Arabia’s
production arm which featured Sheikh Sultan bin Bajad
al-Oteibi (aka Abu Abdul Rahman al-Athari), who was
purportedly killed in the attacks of December 29, 2004. Al-Oteibi
laid out the reasons for Al Qaeda’s sustained attacks on Saudi Arabia, saying,
“At this time, traitors have come to rule us, servants of America… they
betrayed noble Jerusalem and gave it to the Jews, and opened up the country of
the Two Holy Mosques to the soldiers of the Jews and Christians. Muslims, these
rulers have allied the Jews and Christians, and helped them against the
Muslims.” Al-Oteibi also suggested that the battle of
the mujahideen extends far beyond Saudi Arabia: “As to our targets, and our
path in battle: these pertain to the Jews and Christians. We will target their
interests everywhere. We advise all Muslims and all wise infidels who are
guarding these interests or who are working in them, to leave them and not even
to come close to them. The Mujahideen might attack them at any moment.”4
Istanbul, Turkey
On November 15, 2003.
two cars exploded at the Beth Israel and Neve Shalom synagogues in Istanbul.
Five days later, on November 20, two nearly simultaneous trucks detonated at
the British consulate and the local branch of HSBC Bank. The four bombings that
rocked Istanbul killed 58 people and wounded 750 others. Connections of the
local cell to Al Qaeda became evident soon after the attacks based on several
arrests, including that of Fevzi Yitiz, who was
arrested less than a month after the attacks near the Iranian border. Yitiz told his interrogators that two organizers of the
Istanbul cell, Habib Aktas and Ibrahim Kus, met Osama
bin Laden in Afghanistan in 2002, expressing their interest to the Al Qaeda
leaders that they wanted to stage an attack in Turkey for the sake of Jihad. Aktas, a Turkish citizen of Arab origin, appears to be the
originator of the plan, and became the crucial connecting link between Al
Qaeda’s core leadership and the local cell, and also provided the know-how for
the bomb production.5 During Aktas’ visits to the
burgeoning terrorist cells in Istanbul, much of his influence stemmed from his
ongoing experience on the various jihadist battlefields, and his apparent
connections with the Al Qaeda leadership. He benefited greatly from the
prestige of being in touch with the commanders, as well as his personal
religious charisma as a jihadist practitioner. Confession reports show that
local operatives viewed him as an almost holy figure.5 Bin Laden reportedly
suggested an attack at Incirlik air base or against U.S. or Israeli ships using
the Mediterranenan port of Mersin. Stringent security
at the air base and the Mersin harbor, however, made the attack too difficult
to carry out. This led the conspirators, many of whom have trained in
Afghanistan, to change the attack plans.6
Another central
figure in the plot was Louai Sakka, who was arrested on August 6, 2005. Two
days earlier, Sakka’s apartment blew up as he was assembling a bomb intended
for an attack using an explosives-laden yacht which he wanted to steer into a
cruise ship filled with American soldiers. After the Istanbul bombings, Sakka
traveled to Iraq, where he was known as “Louai al-Turki” and participated in
insurgent operations in Fallujah. An indictment released February 10,2006,
charges that Sakka “proposed” the attacks, with specific approval from Osama
bin Laden and Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. He provided all the funds for the attacks,
“with the largest instalment delivered in a sock stuffed with euros from Saudi
sympathizers,” according to the indictment. In Iraq, he helped organize the
insurgent attack on Abu Ghraib, where other organizers of Istanbul bombings
were detained.7 Possible motives for radical Islamists to attack Turkey are not
difficult to fathom. Local militant Islamic groups such as the Great Eastern
Islamic Raiders’ Front (IBDA/C) and the Turkish Hizballah, as well as global
jihadists such as Al Qaeda hold Turkey in contempt for a variety of reasons.
Following World War I, Atatürk transformed Turkey into a secular state and
abolished first the sultanate and then the caliphate in 1924. More recently,
Turkey’s orientation toward the West, such as its efforts to be included in the
European Union; its status as the only Muslim state who is a member of NATO;
its strong political, economic, and military ties to the United States and
Israel; and its support of U.S. military engagements in Afghanistan and Iraq
have provided Al Qaeda with a variety of incentives to launch attacks on the
most democratic of Muslim majority states.
Chechnya
The first suicide
bombing in Chechnya took place on June 7, 2000, when a Chechen man and a
Chechen woman detonated a bomb-laden truck at a checkpoint on the compound of
the elite Omsk OMON unit at Alkhan-Yurt in Chechnya.
The suicide attackers received support from other rebels who hid in a nearby
forest, and fired at the Russian forces after the explosion. Only four days
later, a former Russian soldier who converted to Islam carried out another SA
at a checkpoint in Khankala, killing two senior OMON
sergeants.8 Chechen rebels staged five more SAs on Russian positions on July 2
and July 3, in which at least 33 soldiers were killed, 84 wounded, and six more
were missing.9 From the very outset, the Chechen conflict had elements of a
global struggle. Rather than attempting to keep the focus on its Russian enemy,
the Chechen rebels noted on their official website (www.qoqaz.net) after their
first SA that the operation was meant as a message to all Muslims. The
operation, according to the rebels, “was a cry that said no to the crimes
against the Muslim Ummah, but will the people of the Ummah heed to this call
and rush to support their brothers and sisters who are in need? Will the hearts
of the believers come alive with this example of pure faith and courageous sacrifice?”10In
the following years, several suicide attacks by Chechen groups were carried
out, most of them by the so-called Black Widows—the only exclusively named
female suicide bombing group that adheres to Salafi-Jihadist principles. On
December 27, 2002, three Chechen bombers drove a truck and a car devastated a
government center in the Chechen capital of Grozny that housed a pro-Russian
regional government. On May 14, 2003, a woman suicide bomber who apparently
intended to assassinate the pro-Russian leader of Chechnya, Ahmad Kadyrov,
killed at least 15 people during a religious festival in Ilishkan.
The attack came only two days after a truck bombing aimed at a compound housing
Chechen officials in Znamenskoye had killed at least
59 people. Shamil Basayev, an Islamic warlord killed in early July 2006,
claimed responsibility for both attacks.11 Roughly three weeks later, another
woman bomber detonated herself near a bus carrying military workers from the
town of Mozdok to a Russian air base, killing at
least 18 people, including many women. On July 5, two women detonated
themselves within ten minutes at the entrances of the Tushino Aerodrome, a
north Moscow airfield, during a rock festival attended by 30,000 fans. The
blasts killed at least 16 people and wounded perhaps four times as many. The
bombs were equipped with ball bearings and metal fragments to maximize the
effects of the blasts. In 2004, suicide bombers detonated themselves in the
Moscow subway on February 2004, and outside a subway entrance in August of that
year. Altogether, some 40 Chechen suicide bombers have staged approximately 26
SAs in Chechnya and Russia between June 2000 and December 2005. If we are to
include the two hostage situations of the Moscow theater and the seizure of a
middle school in Beslan—attacks that are not traditional SAs, but where the
attackers professed an expectation to die in the course of the attack—the total
number of Chechen suicide attackers is 112, including 48 women and 64 men, who
have claimed the lives of 939 people and wounded 2913.12 Chechnya is a valuable
case study in demonstrating how an originally localized conflict has adopted
the global characteristics of Salafi-Jihadism. After the Soviet-Afghan war,
Central Asian countries and the Caucasus were a favored destination for
hundreds of recently unemployed Afghan Arabs, who wanted to recreate their
victory against the Soviet Union. In the early 1990s, small groups of Afghan
Arab fighters arrived in Chechnya, influenced by the conflicts in Abkhazia and
Nagorno-Karabach. In the subsequent decade and a
half, this small group would have a tremendous effect in shaping the conflict
and the struggle against Russia that would far surpass their relatively small
numbers.13 Along with their manpower, these fighters brought with them
experience, money, and the Salafi-Jihadist ideology which at the time was
relatively unknown in the Sufi-dominated region.14
Despite the
predominance of the Sufi tradition of Islam in Chechnya and the relative
indifference to Salafism, Salafi-Jihadist ideology was able to gain a foothold
in Chechnya when the need for money to face the militarily superior Russian
enemy became evident. That money was provided mostly by Saudis, with the
understanding that the Saudis would be allowed to build mosques and schools in
Chechnya that would promote Wahhabism in Chechnya.15 The arrival of the Afghan
Arabs was accompanied by the distribution of Salafi-Jihadist (known locally
mostly as Wahhabist) literature, including the wide
circulation of a book called One God, which rejected local cultural influences
of Islam. 16 Foreign funds helped establish Wahhabist
schools and mosques where students and preachers were urged not only to repel
the Russians from Chechnya, but to join the jihad against all infidels in the
name of God.17The Afghan Arabs and subsequent jihadists they attracted from a
variety of places, some of the 9/11 hijackers, for example, had wanted to fight
in Chechnya until they were ordered to participate in the ‘planes operation’ of
9/11, were relatively scattered until 1995, when the foreign fighters organized
under Omar ibn al-Khattab, a Jordanian jihadist who had fought in Afghanistan
and Tajikistan. Khattab had reportedly trained in Al Qaeda-affiliated training
camps in Afghanistan, and shared personnel and resources with the Al Qaeda
leader. Once in Chechnya, Khattab became operations chief under Shamil Basayev,
the overall commander who had close personal ties with bin Laden.18 Following
the end of the first Russian-Chechen war in 1996, foreign jihadis were able to
expand their influence. The Chechen government, expecting the confrontation
with Russia to resume at a future time, asked Khattab to establish a center in
which both local and foreign fighters would be trained in such tactics as mine
laying and ambushing, while receiving a Wahhabist
indoctrination. Some 2,500 fighters were trained in these camps between the
first and second war, according to estimates by Russian authorities.19After
1997, a growing number of Chechen commanders adopted Wahhabism as their creed
and slowly helped turn the Chechen struggle from one dominated mostly by
ethnonationalist motivations to one in which nationalist motivations are joined
by religious motives. This confluence of local and global characteristics is
visible in the current, second installment of the Chechen-Russian war, which
began in 1999.20
Afghanistan
SAs were introduced
in Afghanistan with the killing of Ahmed Shah Masood, the commander of the
Northern Alliance, on September 9, 2001. From the fall of the Taliban until May
2005, the use of this tactic was relatively rare, with only five Sas perpetrated
mostly against the International Security Assistance Force (ISAF).21 The number
of Sas jumped in mid-2005, when the Taliban began employing Sas with growing
frequency mostly against NATO targets. Afghans, however, were targeted as well.
On June 1, a suicide bomber detonated himself at a funeral ceremony at a mosque
in the southern city of Kandahar, killing 19 people, including the Kabul police
chief, and wounded over 50. By the end of 2005, over 15 Sas had targeted mostly
military forces, including a British Embassy convoy, a convoy of Afghan
soldiers, German peacekeepers, as well as U.S. and Canadian forces.22 According
to UN officials in Afghanistan, in the first nine months of 2006, over 60 Sas
were executed in Afghanistan, with the number of civilian deaths rising to 150
in that period.23 On January 5, 2006, a suicide bomber attempted to assassinate
U.S. ambassador Ronald Neumann, who was visiting U.S. troops in the town of Tirin Kot. He failed to hit the ambassador, but killed ten
Afghans and wounded 50 more in the process. 11 days later, the southern border
town of Spin Boldak was the arena of the most fatal
SA in Afghanistan to that date, when 22 people were killed when a suicide
bomber rammed a motorcycle into a crowd during a wrestling match. The attack
came a day after Canadian diplomat Glyn Berry was killed in Kandahar by a
suicide attacker. High-profile Sas continued into the fall of 2006. In August,
Sas in Kandahar and Helmand provinces killed nearly 40 people.24 In September
2006, Sas targeted an American military vehicle, killing 16; a provincial
governor and close friend of President Hamid Karzai; a NATO patrol, killing
four Canadians; and a security checkpoint near the governor’s office in Lashkar
Gah in southern Helmand.25 In some of the cases, SA cells have used mosques to
plan their operations and to store weapons and explosives.26
Sas in Afghanistan
were adopted by Taliban first of all for their tactical efficiency. Asked by a
Christian Science Monitor reporter why the Taliban adopted suicide missions,
Taliban spokesman Mohammad Hanif answered, “this is an effective way of destroying
our enemy. It is a tactic that has been used by mujahideen all over the
world.”27 Clearly, however, the Taliban uses this tactic to increase its
visibility as well. The Taliban’s goal is to topple the regime of Hamid Karzai,
who is regarded as a puppet of the United States, and to drive out foreign
forces from Afghanistan. The composition of Afghan suicide bombers remains
unclear, but it is all but certain that both Afghans as well as non-Afghans are
among the self-described martyrs. In early February 2006, Afghan police
arrested a citizen of Mali who apparently planned to assassinate a governor of
a northern province. A Bangladeshi was reportedly arrested in connection with
Sas a day later.28 In February 2006, the New York Times reported that arrests of
interrogations of suspects believed to be involved in the series of Sas that
rocked Afghanistan in the Winter of 2005/2006 revealed that the attacks were
orchestrated from Pakistan by members of the ousted Taliban government.
According to interrogation tapes, suspects said that the bombers are recruited
in the Pakistani city of Karachi and are then moved to safe houses on the
Pakistani side of the Afghan-Pakistan border, before being transferred into
Afghanistan. The tapes appeared to confirm what Afghan officials had long
claimed, namely that most suicide bombers appeared to be foreigners. A Taliban
spokesman, however, quickly dismissed these claims as government propaganda,
and insisted that all the suicide bombers were Afghan.29 According to an
October 2006 report in the Sunday Times, captured Taliban fighters and failed
suicide bombers told Afghan security services that they had been trained by the
Pakistani Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI).30 In the few videos featuring
wills of suicide bombers who have attacked targets in Afghanistan,
Salafi-Jihadist ideology is clearly reflected. One video released features the
will of a suicide bomber who introduces himself as Amanullah Ghazi from the
province of Khost. Ghazi decries the “infidels” who have “defiled” Afghanistan,
where they are “misleading” Muslims from the righteous path. He then invokes fard ayn, the notion that each
Muslim must join the jihad if Islam is under attack, saying, “it is the duty of
every Muslim to sacrifice oneself in the path of God.” Ghazi also urges other
Muslims to follow his lead, adding that the Quran offers the martyr paradise.
“Inshallah, I will meet you in paradise,” Ghazi says.31Another video features
an unidentified suicide bomber who attacked Canadian soldiers in October 2005,
and features footage of Osama bin Laden calling for the expulsion of “infidels”
from Islamic lands through jihad.32 While no solid information about the
composition of suicide bombers in Afghanistan exists, the Taliban’s use of Sas,
especially in 2006, appeared increasingly sophisticated and more closely
resembling the use of this tactic in Iraq. In Afghanistan, the growing
sophistication is reflected in a rising number of fatalities of Sas, which in
the course of 2006 increasingly claimed double-digit death tolls. Military and
intelligence officials in Afghanistan quoted in the New York Times, however,
were not sure whether the tactics and technologies used in Afghanistan have
been imported from Iraq, or if Afghan insurgents merely copied the tactics used.33
Egypt
Beginning in 2004, a
number of devastating SAs targeted Egypt, the birthplace of the jihadist
movement. On October 7, 2004, three suicide bombers targeted two popular Sinai
resorts, killing 34 people, including 13 Israeli vacationers, and injured some
170 others. One suicide bomber detonated a car bomb at the Taba Hilton, which
led to most fatalities. A second suicide bomber detonated himself at bungalow
campgrounds at Ras a-Sultan, while a third attacker died close by when his car
bomb detonated prematurely before reaching its target.34 On April 7, 2005, a
suicide bomber detonated himself at Cairo’s main bazaar as he fled the
authorities, killing two French tourists and a U.S. citizen.35 Nine months
later on the southern tip of the Sinai peninsula, on July 23, 2005, three
powerful explosions hit the popular Red Sea resort of Sharm el-Sheikh, killing
at least 64 people and wounding over 150 in the most deadly terrorist attack in
Egyptian history. Two suicide attackers detonated bomb-laden cars near the city’s
‘Old Market’ bazaar and the Ghazala Gardens Hotel on the city’s beachfront. A
third suicide bomber detonated a suitcase filled with explosives near a taxi
rank. Although several groups linked to Al Qaeda took responsibility for the
attacks, and despite reports of heightened Al Qaeda activity on the Sinai
peninsula,36 Egyptian authorities initially insisted the bombers, who
reportedly were from Al Arish, were Egyptians of Bedouin origin with no
apparent links to international organizations.37 In March 2006, however, as the
investigation into the bombings proceeded, Egyptian authorities began
acknowledging links between the local Bedouin cell responsible for the bombing
to Al Tawhid w’al Jihad, a group with links to
international Islamists. The authorities also suggested that the cell
responsible for the Sharm el-Sheikh attacks was also responsible for the 2004
bombings in Taba.38
The next major SA in
Egypt was targeted at the resort town of Taba on the Gulf of Aqaba. The attack,
which occurred on April 24, 2006, killed at least 23 people and injured over
80, and bore all the hallmarks of an attack organized by, or at least inspired,
by Al Qaeda.39 Two days later, two bombers targeted Egyptian police and a
U.S.-led multinational peacekeeping force, but killed only themselves in the
process.40 It remains unknown whether the SAs in Egypt that began in 2004 have
been planned and executed by local Egyptian Islamists, perhaps of Bedouin
origins, nationalists, international jihadists like Al Qaeda, or perhaps a
combination of local elements holding a grudge against the Egyptian regime and
a steering hand of Al Qaeda. That Al Qaeda regards the Mubarak regime as
apostate is undisputed. An attack on Egypt would certainly conform with the
priority of traditional jihadist groups on the near enemy, as called for by
radical Islamist preachers such as Faraj and Zawahiri prior to his adoption of the
notion of the primacy of attacks against the far enemy.41 It cannot be ruled
out that Bedouin elements, particularly those in the northern part of the
Sinai, who are impoverished and whose relationships with the regime in Cairo
have been particularly bad, have decided to adopt violence to express their
resentment against the regime.42 Traditional resentments against the regime are
harbored not only due to economic destitution, over 90% of the local Bedouin
population depends on low-paying, seasonal work, but also because of Cairo’s
interference in local and tribal affairs, a gross infraction in a region where
tribal identity far outweighs national patriotism. Disillusionment and
hostility toward the national government has led many young Bedouins to adopt Islam
as their main identity.43 If Bedouin tribes from the north are responsible for
the bombings, as the Mubarak regime claims, they are likely influenced by the
message of Al Qaeda, and are possibly supported financially and/or materially
from abroad.44
Pakistan
Suicide attacks, once
a rarity in Pakistan, are now a common tactic used to attack Pakistani
government and military targets, foreigners, as well as the Shia community.
Pakistan which, according to Ahmed Rashid, “remains the global center for
terrorism and for the remnants of Al Qaeda,”45 is also believed to support
jihadist groups in Kashmir, some of which have begun to adopt suicide terrorism
tactics in April 2000.46 On November 19, 1995, a suicide bomber rammed a
bomb-laden truck into the Egyptian Embassy in the Pakistani capital of
Islamabad, killing 15 people and wounding at least 59 more. Though aimed at
Egypt, the attack, which was carried out by the Egyptian Islamic Group, was the
first suicide operation in Pakistan.47 The first Pakistani suicide bomber was a
middle-class woman who, on November 6, 2000, entered the advertising section of
Pakistan’s most widely circulated newspaper, asking to place a small ad. She
detonated shortly after placing a call on her mobile phone in which she was
heard saying, “I am in the right place.”48
Between 2000 and
mid-2003, most SAs attributed to Pakistanis or to groups supported by Pakistan
occurred in Kashmir or targeted foreigners in Pakistan. SAs were first employed
by radical Islamist groups in Kashmir and India beginning in April 2000. On December
25, 2000, a 24-year old Muslim from Birmingham who had joined the
Salafi-Jihadist Jaesh-e-Muhammad (JeM), rammed a
booby-trapped car into the Indian army’s headquarters in Srinagar, killing 9
people.49 Almost a year later, on December 13, 2001, a spectacular SA targeted
the Indian parliament, killing seven people. India blamed Lashkar-e-Taibeh
(Army of the Pure, LeT) for the attack, a group that
had declared war on India and aims to drive the world’s largest democracy from
the predominantly Muslim region of Kashmir, a border area that India claims for
itself.50
See Case Study: Kashmir P.1 and P.2:
A number of radical Islamist groups would employ SAs
against foreigners, Shia groups, and Pakistani government targets. On May 8,
2002, eleven French citizens were killed along with 3 Pakistanis, when a
suicide bomber detonated himself in a car parked next to the Sheraton hotel in
the port city of Karachi, which is frequented by foreign businessmen.51 Some
five weeks later, a suicide car bomb detonated outside the U.S. consulate in
Karachi, killing 11 and injuring over 20. In March 2006, a U.S. foreign service
officer, David Foy, and three others were killed in a SA. Additional attacks
against American and other foreign targets were prevented by Pakistani security
services.52 High-profile SAs against Shias, who account for roughly 15% of
Pakistan’s 140 million citizens, began on July 4, 2003, when three suicide
bombers detonated themselves during Friday prayers at the Hazara Mosque in the
southwestern city of Quetta in an attack that killed 47 Shia Muslims and
injured over 60. Lashkar-e-Jangvi (LeJ), a radical
anti-Shia terrorist outfit linked to the Sipah-e-Sahaba
group, was held responsible for this and many other attacks against Shias that
were to follow.53 Other SAs on Shiite mosque took place in February 2004, when
60 Shiites died after two suicide bombers attacked a religious procession in
Quetta, in May 2004 in Karachi, in an attack that killed 15 and wounded ten
times as many,54 as well as in October 2004, when 30 Shias were killed during
Friday prayers in Sialkot. The attacks on the Shia spurred a number of Shii counter-attacks on Sunnis, thus raising the specter of
ethnic strife.55 Similar attacks targeting the Shia community and its leaders
occurred throughout 2005 and 2006.56
Pakistani groups,
perhaps aided by foreign Jihadists, also made several attempts on the lives of
key government targets, including individuals and Pakistani security forces. On
December 25, 2003, two suicide attackers driving pickup trucks carrying some 50
pounds of explosives attempted to ram President Musharraf’s motorcade on a main
road in Rawalpindi. The assassination attempt was the second on the Pakistani
President in 11 days, and the third attempt on his life using SAs.57 On July
30, 2004, Pakistan’s designated prime minister, Shaukat Aziz, narrowly escaped
an assassination attempt in a suicide bombing that killed five people,
including Aziz’ driver.58 In the summer of 2006, SAs and the use of improvised
explosive devices (IEDs) against government security forces also surged in
Waziristan, in Pakistan’s tribal belt.59 It is also worth mentioning that
radical Islamists and Salafi-Jihadists of Pakistani origin have played
prominent roles in SAs in the West. In the United Kingdom, three of the four London
bombers, Mohammed Siddique Khan, Shehzad Tanweer, and Hasib Mir Hussein, were
of Pakistani origin. British citizens of Pakistani origin also dominated the
composition of over 20 would-be-bombers involved in the August 2006 plot to
detonate airliners en route from Western Europe to
the United States. Many of the suspects in that plot had close family ties to
Pakistan residing in Pakistan, suggesting an apparently close ideological and
organizational affinity of British suspects of Pakistani origins to elements in
Pakistan proper.60
Pakistani journalist
Nasra Hassan explains that SAs resonate with many Pakistanis because of a
prevailing environment of humiliation and resulting rage, coupled with sermons
by Arab militants who fled Afghanistan and an endorsement by Pakistani clerics.
61 Based on interviews she conducted with numerous leaders, planners, and
trainers of groups sponsoring Sas, Hassan concludes that on an individual
level, Pakistani suicide bombers cannot be distinguished from overall Pakistani
males. Hassan’s data shows that most Pakistani suicide bombers are between
18-30, mostly from the middle, lower-middle, and poorer classes, and
predominantly single. All cited Osama bin Laden as a hero. They justified their
willingness to perpetrate martyrdom operations with the need to defend Islam
and a desire to exact revenge for the betrayal of Al Qaeda and the Taliban, as
well as for the government’s bowing to external pressure. The issues of
Palestine, Jerusalem, Iraq, and Chechnya were not cited. Hassan also found that
most suicide bombers had obtained training in special camps or had previously
fought in Afghanistan, Kashmir, or both. The vast majority of Pakistani suicide
bombers returned to jihad after a period of break, during which most were
gainfully employed.62 In terms of organizations, Hassan writes that the jihadi
groups in Pakistan involved in Sas are closely linked to other groups in
Pakistan and abroad. Several of these organizations cooperate closely with each
other, oftentimes loaning or bartering militans,
expertise, supplies, and funds to their allies. At times, members of different
groups swarm together to execute a SA, and group members often switch
affiliations.63
Uzbekistan
In April 2004, the
Islamic Jihad Group (IJG), an organization responsible for a number of violent
attacks in Uzbekistan, carried out a series of SAs around Tashkent and Bukhara,
in which 47 people were killed. The attacks targeted both political and civilian
targets, including local government offices and a crowded market. An offshoot
of the Islamic Movement of Turkestan (formerly the Islamic Movement of
Uzbekistan, IMU), the IJG is on the U.S. State Department’s list of Specially
Designated Global Terrorist Groups. A statement in which the IJG claimed
responsibility for simultaneous bombing attacks against the U.S. and Israeli
embassies and the Uzbek Prosecutor General reveals the Salafi-Jihadist nature
of IJG”A group of young Muslims executed martyrdom operations that put fear in
the apostate government and its infidel allies, the Americans and Jews. The
mujahidin belonging to Islamic Jihad Group attacked both the American and
Israeli embassies as well as the court building where the trials of a large number
of the brothers from the Group had begun. These martyrdom operations that the
group is executing will not stop, God willing. It is for the purpose of
repelling the injustice of the apostate government and supporting the jihad of
our Muslim brothers in Iraq, Palestine, Afghanistan, the Hijaz, and in other
Muslim countries ruled by infidels and apostates.”64
1. Syed Rashid
Husain, Al-Khobar, and Peter Conradi, "Al-Qaeda Pledges War on Saudi Oil
Plants," Sunday Times, 26 February 2006.
2. Schweitzer and
Ferber, "Al Qaeda and the Internationalization of Suicide Terrorism,"
72.
3. See also Whitlock,
"Al Qaeda Shifts Its Strategy in Saudi Arabia," 28.
4. "Blood That
Will Not Have Flown in Vain - a Video Presentation of the Martyrs of Saudi
Arabia, Issued by Al-Qaeda in Saudi Arabia," SITE Institute, 28 April
2006.
5. Former Turkish
counterterrorism official, interview with the author, Istanbul, Turkey, 10 June
2005.
6. Former Turkish
counterterrorism official, interview with the author, Istanbul, Turkey, 10 June
2005.
7. Selcan Hacaoglu, "Bin Laden
Proposed Attacks on U.S. Military Base in Turkey, but Militants Switched
Targets," Associated Press, 17 December 2003.
8. Karl Vick, "A
Bomb-Builder, 'out of the Shadow'," Washington Post, 6 February 2006.
9.Reuven Paz,
"Suicide Terrorist Operations in Chechnya: An Escalation of the Islamist
Struggle," International Policy Institute for Counter-Terrorism (ICT), 20
June 2000.
10. Dodge
Billingsley, "Chechen Rebels Hone Tactics for Long Haul," Jane's
Intelligence Review 13, no. 2 (1 February 2001).
11. Quoted in Paz,
"Suicide Terrorist Operations in Chechnya," ICT, 20 June 2000.
12. Michael Wines,
"19 Die as Suicide Bomber Destroys Bus near Chechnya," New York
Times, 6 June 2003, A1.
13. The numbers here
are based not on the NSSC database, but on data provided in Anne Speckhard and Khapta Ahkmedova, "The
Making of a Martyr: Chechen Suicide Terrorism," Studies in Conflict and
Terrorism 29, no. 5 (July-August 2006). On the theater takeover, see especially
Anne Speckhard et al., "Research Note: Observations of Suicidal Terrorists
in Action," Terrorism and Political Violence 16, no. 2 (2004).
14. Lorenzo Vidino, "The Arab Foreign Fighters and the
Sacralization of the Chechen Conflict," Al Nakhlah
(Spring 2006), 1.
15. Dmitri V. Trenin, Aleksei V. Malashenko, and Anatol Lieven, Russia’s
Restless Frontier: The Chechnya Factor in Post-Soviet Russia (Washington, D.C.:
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace,2004).
16. Vidino, "The Arab Foreign Fighters and the
Sacralization of the Chechen Conflict," 2.
17. Speckhard and Ahkmedova, "The Making of a Martyr," 445.
18. Ibid..
19. Mark Riebling and
R.P. Eddy, "Jihad@Work: Behind the Moscow
Theater Attack," National Review Online, 24 October 2002).
20. Trenin, Malashenko, and Lieven, Russia’s Restless Frontier:
The Chechnya Factor in Post-Soviet Russia , 94.
21. Carl Robichaud,
"Iraq Tactics Hit Afghanistan," Afghanistan Watch, 9 June 2005.
22. Carlotta Gall and
Eric Schmitt, "Taliban Step up Afghan Bombings and Suicide Attacks,"
New York Times, 21 October 2005, 3. Carlotta Gall, "Suicide Bombers Hit
Peacekeepers in Afghanistan," New York Times, 15 November 2005, 17; David
Rhode, "Suicide Bomber Kills Two Afghans," New York Times 2005, 13;
Carlotta Gall, "2 Die in Attack on Canadians in Afghanistan," New
York Times, 5 December 2005, 8.
23. Carlotta Gall,
"Attacks in Afghanistan Grow More Frequent and Lethal," New York
Times, 27 September 2006, 15.
24. "Afghan
Suicide Bombing Kills 17," BBC News, 28 August 2006; "Kabul Suicide
Bomb Hits Us Convoy," BBC News, 8 September 2006.
25. Carlotta Gall and
Abdul Waheed Wafa, "Suicide Bomber Kills 16 in Kabul near Embassy,"
New York Times, 9 September 2006, 1; Carlotta Gall, "Suicide Bomber Kills
a Governor in Afghanistan," New York Times, 11 September 2006, 1; "Canadians
Die in Afghan Bombing," BBC News, 18 September 2006; Gall,"Attacks
in Afghanistan Grow More Frequent and Lethal," 15.
26. Waliullah
Rahmani, "Afghan Authorities Apprehend Leaders of Kabul Suicide
Cell," Terrorism Focus 3, no. 39 (10 October 2006).
27. Scott Baldauf,
"Taliban Turn to Suicide Attacks," Christian Science Monitor, 3
February 2006, 1.
28. Omid Marzban,
"The Foreign Makeup of Afghan Suicide Bombers," Terrorism Focus 3,
no. 7 (21 February 2007).
29. Gall,
"Afghan Attacks, Tied to Taliban, Point to Pakistan," , 1.
30. Christina Lamb,
"Nato Chief Will Front Musharraf to Demand Taliban Leader Omar's
Arrest," Agence France Press, 9 October 2006, 9.
31. Hekmat Karzai,
"Afghanistan and the Logic of Suicide Terrorism," IDSS Commentaries
20 (27 March 2006).
32. "A Video
Produced by Al-Sahab Media Depicting a Suicide Bomber's Will and Operation
Targeting American Forces in Kabul, Afghanistan," SITE Institute, 30
January 2006.
33. Gall,
"Attacks in Afghanistan Grow More Frequent and Lethal," 15.
34. Matthew Gutman
and Herb Keinon, "Idf Concludes Sinai Rescue
Operation. 13 Israelis among 32 Bombing Victims," Jerusalem Post, 11
October 2004.
35. Heba Saleh,
"Cairo Attacks: Police Hold 200," Financial Times, 2 May 2005, 8.
36. Zeev Schiff,
"Analysis: Dahab Terror Attack Indicative of Egypt's Failure,"
Haaretz, 25 April 2006.
37. "Egypt
Suicide Bombers Were Bedouin Islamists," Agence
France Press, 3 September 2005.
38. Ashraf Sweilam, "Egyptians Kill Three Bombing Suspects,"
Associated Press, 21 November 2005; "Egypt Names Islamist Group Suspected
of Sinai Attacks," Agence France Press, 26 March
2006.
39. Yassin Musharbash, "Bin Laden's
Lange Leine," Spiegel Online, 25 April 2006.
40. Daniel Williams,
"Two Bombers Target Forces in Egypt," Washington Post, 27 April 2006,
A14.
41. Reuven Paz,
"From Riyadh 1995 to Sinai 2004: The Return of Al-Qaeda to the Arab
Homeland," PRISM Occasional Papers 2, no. 3 (October 2004).
42. Chris Zambelis, "Egypt Attacks May Indicate Emerging Sinai
Bedouin Insurgency," Terrorism Focus 3, no. 19 (17 May 2006).
43. Michael Slackman,
"Out of Desert Poverty, a Caldron of Rage in the Sinai," New York
Times, 7 May 2006, 6.
44. See also Ely
Karmon, "Egypt as a New Front of Al Qaeda," International Policy
Institute for Counter-Terrorism (ICT), 5 May 2006.
45 "Spiegel
Interview with Pakistani Scholar Ahmed Rashid," Spiegel Online, 22 July
2005. Available at http://www.spiegel.de/international/1,1518,366371,00.html
46. For an excellent
overview over jihadi groups in Pakistan and Kashmir, see Stern, Terror in the
Name of God , Chapters 5 and 8. See also Hassan Abbas, Pakistan's Drift into
Extremism: Allah, the Army, and America's War on Terror (Armonk, N.Y.: M.E. Sharpe,
2005).
47. Kathy Gannon,
"Pakistan Suicide Bomber Kills 15; Blast Rocks Egyptian Embassy,"
Chicago Sun-Times, 20 November 1995, 24.
48. Esther Oxford,
"Pakistan Grapples with Menace of Suicide Bombers," Independent, 30
November 2000,18.
49. Sudha
Ramachandran, "Killers Turn to Suicide," Asia Times, 15 October 2004.
50. Celia W. Dugger,
"Group in Pakistan Is Blamed by India for Suicide Raid," New York
Times, 15 December 2001, 1.
51. Farhan Bokhari
and Edward Luce, "Pakistan Bombers Kill 44 at Mosque Suicide Attack on
Shias," Financial Times, 5 July 2003, 11.
52. "Pakistanis
Say They Foiled Anti-U.S. Plot," Associated Press, 16 December 2002.
53. David Rhode,
"47 Pakistanis Die in Attack on Shiite Rites," New York Times, 5 July
2003, 1. For more on Lashkar-e-Jangvi’s use of
suicide attacks, see Nasra Hassan, "Suicide Terrorism," in The Roots
of Terrorism, ed. Louise Richardson (New York: Routledge, 2006).And expecially out two part Case Study above.
54. Kamran Khan,
"Bomber in Karachi Mosque Kills 15," Washington Post, 8 May 2004,
A11.
55. Ramachandran,
"Killers Turn to Suicide," Asia Times, 15 October 2004.
56. Kamran Khan,
"Suicide Bombing in Pakistan Kills 20; Shiites Targeted at Mosque in
Capital," Washington Post, 28 May 2005, A18; Riaz Khan, "Suicide
Bombing and Riots Kill 27 as Pakistan Celebrates Muslim Festival,"
Independent, 10 February 2006, 43; Salman Masood, "A Top Shiite Leader in
Pakistan Dies in a Suicide Bombing," New York Times, 15 July 2006, 3.
57. Matthew
Pennington, "Musharraf Survives Another Suicide Attack," Gazette, 26
December 2003, A20.
58. Farhan Bokhari,
"Pakistan Pm-Elect Survives Suicide Attack," Financial Times, 31 July
2004, 8.
59. Sohail Abdul
Nasir, "Insurgents Switch Tactics in Waziristan," Terrorism Focus 3,
no. 24 (20 June 2006).
60. Yassin
Musharbash, "Die Pakistan-Connection," Spiegel Online, 11 August
2006. Available at http://www.spiegel.de/panorama/0,1518,431334,00.html.
61. Hassan,
"Suicide Terrorism," 33.
62. Ibid., 38-39.
63. Ibid., 34.
64. "Islamic
Jihad Group (Uzbekistan)," Terrorism Knowledge Base. Available online at
http://www.tkb.org.
For updates
click homepage here